Thyroid health

Levothyroxine Side Effects or Under-Treatment?

True side effects from levothyroxine are uncommon. Most of the time, feeling off on Synthroid or Eltroxin comes down to the dose being too high or too low, or the pill not being absorbed well. Here's how to tell the difference.

All articles
Hands holding a ceramic mug of warm water by a window on marble, for a post on levothyroxine side effects

"I think my thyroid medication is making me feel worse"

This is one of the most common things I hear from women on levothyroxine. They're tired, anxious, losing hair or just not themselves, and they wonder if the pill is the problem.

Here's what surprises most people. Levothyroxine is a synthetic version of T4, the same hormone your thyroid makes on its own. Your body recognizes it as its own. So true side effects from the hormone itself are uncommon.

What's much more common is one of three things: the dose is a bit too high, the dose is a bit too low, or the pill isn't being absorbed well. All three can feel like "side effects." The good news is that each one has a different fix.

What is levothyroxine?

Levothyroxine is the most prescribed thyroid medication in Canada. You might know it by a brand name like Synthroid or Eltroxin, or as generic levothyroxine. It replaces the T4 your thyroid can't make enough of, most often because of Hashimoto's.

It's worth remembering that hypothyroidism and Hashimoto's aren't the same thing. Levothyroxine replaces the missing hormone, which is important. It doesn't address the immune side of Hashimoto's, and that's part of why some people still don't feel great on a "perfect" dose.

Signs your levothyroxine dose may be too high

When there's more thyroid hormone than your body needs, everything speeds up. Symptoms of too much Synthroid or levothyroxine can include:

  • A racing, pounding or skipping heartbeat
  • Anxiety, irritability or feeling wired
  • Trouble falling or staying asleep
  • Feeling hot and sweaty when others aren't
  • Shaky hands
  • Loose stools or more frequent bowel movements
  • Weight loss without trying

Over the long term, being overmedicated can affect heart rhythm and bone density, especially after menopause. That's why the goal is the right dose, not the highest one.

Signs you may be under-treated

When the dose is too low, you'll usually feel the opposite. Fatigue that sleep doesn't fix, feeling cold, brain fog, constipation, dry skin, heavier periods, low mood and weight that won't budge. If that list sounds familiar, I go into more detail in hypothyroidism symptoms in women that get missed.

Here's the tricky part. Some symptoms show up on both lists, like anxiety, hair loss and poor sleep. That's why guessing doesn't work. Your labs are what tell the two apart.

True levothyroxine side effects

They're uncommon, but they do happen. The most common ones I see:

  • Reactions to fillers or dyes. Different strengths come in different colours, and some brands contain lactose or other fillers. If symptoms started after a strength or brand change, the inactive ingredients may be the issue. Your pharmacist can help you compare.
  • Temporary hair shedding. Some people notice extra shedding in the first few months after starting or changing their dose. It usually settles as levels stabilize.
  • Feeling off after a brand switch. Brands aren't always perfectly interchangeable. If your pharmacy switches your brand, it's worth rechecking your labs about 6 weeks later.

The hidden problem: absorption

This one is overlooked all the time. Levothyroxine is picky about how it's taken. If it isn't absorbed well, your labs can look under-treated even though you never miss a dose.

Think of it like watering a plant through a funnel. If the funnel is half blocked, the plant stays thirsty no matter how much water you pour.

Things that commonly block absorption:

  • Coffee. Even black coffee taken too soon after your pill can reduce how much you absorb. Wait 30 to 60 minutes.
  • Food. Take it on an empty stomach with water, ideally 30 to 60 minutes before breakfast. Some people do better taking it at bedtime, at least 3 hours after their last meal.
  • Calcium, iron and magnesium. Supplements and antacids can bind to levothyroxine. Keep them about 4 hours apart.
  • Stomach acid medications. Medications like PPIs can lower absorption.
  • Gut issues. Celiac disease, H. pylori and low stomach acid can all play a role.

The key is consistency. Take it the same way, at the same time, every day, so your dose and your labs can be trusted.

Still not feeling like yourself on levothyroxine? Book a free consult and we'll look at your labs, your routine and the bigger picture. JOSIE is virtual and sees patients anywhere in Ontario.

"My labs are normal, but I still feel off"

You're not imagining it. Studies show that a meaningful number of people on levothyroxine still have symptoms, even when their TSH is in range.

A few reasons this happens:

  • "Normal" isn't always optimal. On medication, I generally aim for a TSH between 0.5 and 2.0. I explain the numbers in TSH levels explained.
  • TSH alone doesn't show the full picture. Free T4 and free T3 show how much hormone you have and how much is in its active form.
  • T4 to T3 conversion. Your body has to convert T4 into active T3. Low iron, low selenium, chronic stress and illness can all slow that down.
  • Something else is adding to it. Low ferritin, insulin resistance, low vitamin D or B12, and poor sleep all cause symptoms that look like a thyroid problem.

For some people, adding a T3 medication or switching to another option is worth discussing. I compare them in levothyroxine, liothyronine or NDT.

What to do next

  • Write down your symptoms and when they started. Note any recent dose, brand or routine changes.
  • Check how you're taking it. Empty stomach, water only, and space it from coffee and supplements.
  • Ask for a full thyroid panel. TSH, free T4, free T3 and antibodies, plus ferritin. Test in the morning, before your dose.
  • Recheck 6 weeks after any change. That's how long it takes for levels to settle.
  • Never change your dose on your own. Bring your questions to the person who prescribes your medication.

How a naturopathic doctor can help

At JOSIE, thyroid health is one of my main focus areas. I can review your labs against optimal ranges, look at absorption and conversion, and check the other pieces that affect how you feel. When a medication change might help, I'll explain why and work with your prescriber. Learn more on our thyroid health and specialized testing pages.

Naturopathic visits fall outside OHIP, so there's no rush to get through one lab value and out the door. We take the time to look at your whole routine. If you have extended health benefits, check your naturopathic coverage. JOSIE direct bills most insurers.

The bottom line

Most "levothyroxine side effects" are really a dose that's a bit off or a pill that isn't being absorbed well. Getting the right labs, at the right time, taken the right way, is usually what finally gets you feeling like yourself again.

References

1. Jonklaas J, et al. Guidelines for the treatment of hypothyroidism: prepared by the American Thyroid Association task force on thyroid hormone replacement. Thyroid. 2014;24(12):1670-1751.

2. Benvenga S, et al. Altered intestinal absorption of L-thyroxine caused by coffee. Thyroid. 2008;18(3):293-301.

3. Bolk N, et al. Effects of evening vs morning levothyroxine intake: a randomized double-blind crossover trial. Arch Intern Med. 2010;170(22):1996-2003.

4. Flynn RW, et al. Serum thyroid-stimulating hormone concentration and morbidity from cardiovascular disease and fractures in patients on long-term thyroxine therapy. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2010;95(1):186-193.

5. Saravanan P, et al. Psychological well-being in patients on 'adequate' doses of l-thyroxine: results of a large, controlled community-based questionnaire study. Clin Endocrinol. 2002;57(5):577-585.

6. Peterson SJ, et al. Is a normal TSH synonymous with "euthyroidism" in levothyroxine monotherapy? J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2016;101(12):4964-4973.

7. Liwanpo L, Hershman JM. Conditions and drugs interfering with thyroxine absorption. Best Pract Res Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2009;23(6):781-792.

8. American Thyroid Association. Thyroid hormone treatment. thyroid.org.

For educational purposes, not medical advice.


Dr. Monica Commisso, ND

Looking for personalized support?

If you are looking for more support, detailed testing, and a clear path forward with your health, feel free to book a free consult with me.

— Dr. Monica Commisso, ND

Common questions

About this topic

About the clinic

More from the journal

Keep reading

Overhead flat lay of rosemary, sage, a brass bowl and twine on pale stone, for a post on integrative cancer care in OntarioIntegrative cancer care

Integrative Oncology in Ontario: Who Does What

When you're facing cancer, the titles can get confusing fast. Here's what a medical oncologist, an integrative oncologist and a naturopathic doctor each do in Ontario, and how they can work together.

Read article
Notebook, brass magnifying glass and folded city map on a desk, for a post on choosing a naturopath in TorontoWellness

How to Choose a Naturopath in Toronto and the GTA

Searching "naturopath near me" brings up dozens of options. Here's how to check that an ND is registered, find one whose focus matches what you need, spot red flags, and know what to ask before you book.

Read article
Unlabelled jar of cream, aloe leaf and cotton cloth on linen, for a post on radiation therapy side effects and skin careIntegrative cancer care

Radiation Side Effects: Skin, Fatigue and Recovery

Radiation side effects build slowly, often peak right after your last treatment, then start to ease over the following weeks. Here's what to expect for your skin and energy, what helps, and how long recovery usually takes.

Read article
Brass dial gauge beside a blood test tube on linen, for a post explaining TSH levelsThyroid health

TSH Levels Explained: High, Low and "Normal"

TSH works backwards from how most people expect. High TSH usually means an underactive thyroid, and low TSH usually means an overactive one. Here's what your TSH levels actually mean, and why "normal" doesn't always mean you'll feel your best.

Read article
Naturopathic doctor's desk with a stethoscope, amber tincture bottles, dried herbs and a lab test tubeWellness

What Does a Naturopathic Doctor Actually Do?

A naturopathic doctor is a regulated health care provider who looks for what's driving your symptoms and builds a plan around you. Here's how NDs are trained in Ontario, what a visit looks like and how we work alongside your family doctor.

Read article
Comfort items for chemo on a side table: knit blanket, ginger tea, water bottle, notebook and fresh mintIntegrative cancer care

Chemo Side Effects Week by Week: What to Expect

On a typical 3-week chemo cycle, the first few days bring fatigue and nausea, days 7 to 14 carry the highest infection risk, and week 3 is often the recovery week. Here's what to expect after your first treatment, when to call your team and what can help.

Read article
Cream stone thyroid sculpture with a journal, herbal tea and eucalyptus on linen, for a post on hypothyroidism symptoms in womenThyroid health

Hypothyroidism Symptoms in Women That Get Missed

The hypothyroidism symptoms in women that get missed most often are fatigue that sleep doesn't fix, brain fog, low mood, thinning outer eyebrows, constipation, muscle aches and heavier periods. They're easy to miss when only TSH is tested, or when labs are "normal" but not optimal.

Read article
Editorial still life of a biopsy needle, specimen vial, pathology slides, and medical imaging on a warm neutral surface.Integrative cancer care

Can a Biopsy Make Cancer Spread? Separating Fear From Evidence

For most cancers, no, not in any meaningful way. A biopsy needle can occasionally carry a small number of cells along its path, but true tumor seeding is extremely rare, and biopsies have not been shown to worsen survival in common cancers like breast cancer. The bigger risk, in almost every case, is delaying the diagnosis.

Read article

Ready when you are.

Your health journey isn't meant to be figured out alone. Everything you're experiencing is real and valid — you deserve proper investigation, deep listening, and intentional steps toward optimal health.

Explore our care
Contact